17 Holiday Dog Treat Ideas To Make At Home That Make Store Treats Feel Useless

🔎 Disclosure: Heads up, babe: some links here are affiliate links, which means you might throw a tiny commission my way if you buy (zero extra cost to you). Only things you’d actually use and love get shared on this site.

1. Peanut Butter And Oat Cut Out Holiday Cookies

That dough keeps its shape best when oats are slightly blended so the edges do not crack while baking.

Start This Way: Mix peanut butter with oats and water, roll flat, and cut shapes before baking at 350°F for about 12 minutes.

It will be so convenient if you use holiday cookie cutter set to get clean shapes without extra effort.

2. Pumpkin And Cinnamon Soft Bake Treat Shapes

Pumpkin keeps the dough soft while a pinch of cinnamon gives that warm holiday smell.

Try This Way: Mix pumpkin with flour and cinnamon, roll out, and cut simple shapes before baking.

3. Sweet Potato And Oat Star Shaped Treats

Sweet potato thickens the mix so the stars hold together once baked.

Here’s What To Do: Mash sweet potato with oats, press flat, and cut star shapes before baking.

4. Apple And Carrot Small Crunch Bake Bites

Thin pieces crisp slightly when baked, making them perfect for gifting.

Begin With This: Chop apples and carrots small, mix into dough, and bake until lightly firm.

5. Peanut Butter And Banana Soft Round Cookies

Banana adds moisture so the cookies stay soft even after cooling.

Give This A Try: Mash banana with peanut butter and flour, then bake small rounds.

6. Chicken And Rice Pressed Holiday Squares

Rice helps the chicken hold together so the squares stay firm in gift bags.

Consider This: Mix cooked chicken and rice, press into a pan, bake, and cut into squares.

7. Blueberry And Yogurt Frozen Drop Treats

Yogurt freezes smoother when mixed with mashed berries first.

Picked For You:  19 Homemade Dog Food Recipes For Large Dogs That Make Feeding Easier

Here’s A Quick Way: Mix yogurt with blueberries, spoon drops onto a tray, and freeze.

It will be way faster if you use squeeze bottle for batter to portion clean drops quickly.

8. Pumpkin And Peanut Butter Mini Biscuit Treats

Peanut butter gives the pumpkin dough structure so biscuits hold their shape.

Start Small With This: Mix both with flour, roll out, and cut small biscuit shapes before baking.

9. Oat And Apple Holiday Cookie Cut Shapes

Oats hold the dough together while apple softens it during baking.

Use This Simple Trick: Roll dough flat and cut shapes using cookie cutters.

10. Carrot And Peanut Butter Small Roll Bites

Peanut butter binds the carrot pieces so they roll into firm little bites.

Here’s A Low-Stress Way: Mix both, roll into balls, and chill or bake lightly.

11. Tuna And Rice Savory Holiday Snack Pieces

Rice absorbs moisture from tuna so the mix is easy to shape.

The Less Stressful Way Is: Mix tuna with rice, shape small pieces, and bake until firm.

12. Sweet Potato And Egg Soft Bake Chews

Egg helps hold the sweet potato together so the chews stay firm.

If You Want To Keep It Easy: Mix both with flour and bake small soft pieces.

13. Peanut Butter And Honey Flat Oat Treats

Oats give structure while honey adds a slight sweetness and helps binding.

Start By Doing This Instead: Press the mixture flat on a tray and bake into a thin sheet.

14. Chicken And Sweet Potato Small Cube Treats

Sweet potato binds the chicken so cubes hold together once cooled.

Instead, Try This: Mix both, press into a pan, and cut into cubes after baking.

15. Pumpkin And Banana Holiday Cookie Shapes

Banana softens the pumpkin dough so it is easier to cut shapes.

The Easy First Step Is: Mix both with flour, roll flat, and cut holiday shapes.

Picked For You:  25 Dog Birthday Treat Ideas For Your Pup That Feel Simple But Still Special

16. Oat And Blueberry Soft Bake Treat Rounds

Blueberries blend into the oats and create a soft texture.

If You’re Not Sure Where To Start: Mash berries into oat dough and bake small rounds.

17. Apple And Oat Pressed Holiday Squares

Oats soak up apple juice so the squares hold their shape after baking.

Here’s The Shortcut Version: Press the mix into a pan, bake, and slice into squares.


📌 SAVE IT FOR LATER! 📌


Photo of author

Lily Thompson

Hey, I'm Lily! I'm a mom who's really good at two things: making life easier and sharing what works. I created ''Like Mom Said'' after one too many moments of realizing: "My mom was right about this." Turns out, a lot of that old-school wisdom still holds up... it just needs a modern spin. Think of me as your friend who's always got a tip (and coffee in hand.)